You are here:
Home
Arizona
Law
Buying an Arizona
BusinessLegal Issues When Buying an Arizona Business - Frequently Asked
Questions
by Richard Keyt, Arizona transactions and
business attorney
Have you found an Arizona business for sale that you would like to buy or are
you thinking about buying a business for sale in Arizona?
Buying a business may be the most expensive investment you ever make, especially
if you do not do your homework and do not have properly drafted legal documents that protect your
investment. In theory, buying a business is relatively simple. The
buyer signs a purchase contract, pays the money, takes possession and begins
operating the business. Alas, if only it were that simple.
When you spend a lot of money to purchase a business, you should make
sure that your purchase documents give you the legal protection that the
investment deserves. This article answers questions
frequently asked by prospective buyers about legal considerations arising from
buying an Arizona business.
Table of Contents
- What are Two Common Methods of Buying a Business?
- What is an Entity Purchase?
- What is an Asset Purchase?
- Should I Buy an Entity or the Assets?
- Is there a Tax Benefit to an Asset Purchase?
- Which Sales Method Do Sellers Usually Prefer?
- How Do I Determine Which Sales Method to Use?
- How Can the Buyer Minimize Post-closing Problems?
- What is Adequate Due Diligence?
- What About Real Estate Due Diligence?
- Can a Buyer Cancel a Purchase if there is a
Problem?
- Can a Buyer Close if Problems are Not
Resolved?
- What Legal Documents are Used in a
Business Purchase?
- Can You Explain the Common Purchase Documents?
- Can an Arizona Business Broker Prepare
the Contracts?
- Is Earnest Money Required to Have a Binding
Contract?
- What is an Escrow?
- Is an Escrow Necessary?
- Arizona Business Buyer's Additional Legal
Issues
- KEYTLaw's Business Purchase Document
Preparation Service
- KEYTLaw's Business Purchase Document
Review Service
What are Two Common Methods of Buying a Business?
Almost all purchases and sales of businesses involve either a purchase of the
company that owns the business (an "entity purchase") or the purchase of the
assets of a business (an "asset purchase").
What is an Entity Purchase?
An entity purchase occurs when the buyer purchases the interest of the people or
entities that own the company that owns the business. Most businesses
today are owned and operated by a corporation, limited liability company or a
partnership. An entity purchase occurs if the buyer buys all of: (i) the
stock of a corporation, (ii) the membership interests of a limited liability
company, or (iii) the partnership interests of a partnership.
When an entity purchase occurs, the buyer steps into the shoes of and replaces
the prior owner(s) of the entity that owns and operates a business. The
public may or may not know that there is a new owner. The title to all the
assets of the business remains in the name of the entity.
An asset purchase occurs when the buyer purchases all or some of the assets of a
business. The buyer does not acquire any ownership interest in the company
that owns the business. The owners of the business remain the same.
Should I Buy an Entity or the Assets?
Most businesses are purchased using the asset purchase method. The primary
reason prudent buyers insist on an asset purchase is because they do not want to
acquire liabilities of the entity that they are not willing to assume. The
general rule with respect to an asset purchase is that the buyer is liable only
for liabilities of the seller specifically assumed in the purchase agreement.
A buyer that buys all the stock of a corporation (or other entity) that owns a
business indirectly bears the burden of all liabilities of the corporation (or
the entity), known and unknown. The entity is not affected by the sale of
the owners' interest, which means that the company remains liable for all of its
contracts, employee issues, lease obligations, tort liabilities such as claims
for negligence and products liability and all other obligations of the entity.
When you buy the assets of a business, you should negotiate with the seller as
to what liabilities of the company, if any, you will assume and be liable to
satisfy after closing. An asset purchase agreement should expressly state
the liabilities of the seller for which the buyer will be liable and that the
buyer is not liable for any liabilities of the seller that are not expressly
assumed in the asset purchase agreement.
Is there a Tax Benefit to an Asset Purchase?
Another reason to use an asset purchase rather than an entity purchase is to
obtain a stepped-up tax basis in the purchased assets, which may result in
greater tax write offs for the buyer. When you purchase an entity, the tax
basis of the entities assets may be unaffected and retain their fully or
partially depreciated values. In general, the seller and the buyer may
allocate the purchase price among the purchased assets and the allocation
between unrelated parties will be respected by the IRS.
Which Sales Method Do Sellers Usually Prefer?
Most of the time sellers prefer to sell their ownership interest in the entity
rather than sell assets of the entity because they can report their entire gain
on their tax returns as capital gains. With an asset sale, the tax basis
of the assets sold may have been fully or partially depreciated and/or subject
to recapture which results in the seller reporting large amounts of ordinary
income. If the seller is a corporation, the stockholders may suffer double
taxation when the corporation first reports and pays tax on the gain from the
sale and then distributes the after tax proceeds to the stockholders who must
report the net amount on their personal tax returns and pay a second tax.
How Do I Determine Which Sales Method to Use?
The interests of the buyer and seller are exactly the opposite when it comes to
their preferred method to sell a business. Sellers generally prefer the
entity purchase, and buyers generally prefer the asset purchase.
Ultimately, the method is negotiable and the agreed on by the parties.
How Can the Buyer Minimize Post-closing Problems?
The three most important things a buyer can to do to minimize the risk of
post-closing problems are: (i) adequate due diligence before becoming
obligated to purchase, (ii) document the transaction with properly drafted
legal documents, and (iii) obtain personal guaranties of the selling entity's
obligations under the purchase agreement unless you are certain that the selling
entity will always have the assets to satisfy any breaches of the purchase
agreement and related documents.
Adequate due diligence depends on the facts and circumstances of each particular
purchase. Buyers should consult with their advisors, including their
accountant and attorney, to determine what constitutes adequate due diligence
for their purchase.
There is no substitute for adequate pre-closing due diligence. A
prospective buyer of a business must investigate all important aspects of the
business and owner's operation of the business because what the buyer does not
know can come back to haunt the buyer after closing.
Adequate due diligence should include the following at a minimum:
-
Investigate all entities involved in the transaction and confirm that the
entities exist and are in good standing. It is very common for people
to operate a business under a name that is different from the actual legal name
of the entity or to operate as an entity after the government has revoked the
entity's legal existence. Confirm the exact name of all entities involved
in the transaction and make sure that all documents reflect the correct name(s).
Parties to a transaction should always demand and receive a certificate from the
proper governmental authority that shows that the entity exists and is in good
standing with its state of formation.
To confirm if a purported Arizona corporation or limited liability company
exists and is in good standing, contact the Arizona Corporation Commission and
order a Certificate of Good Standing. You can do a preliminary search for
Arizona entities on the
ACC's website.
If an entity is not formed in Arizona, you must confirm its existence and get a
Certificate of Good Standing or equivalent from the state in which the entity
was formed. If an out of state entity is qualified to do business in
Arizona, you can obtain a Certificate of Good Standing for the entity from the
ACC.
-
Obtain written evidence of proper authority for an entity to sign the
purchase agreement and related documents and to consummate the transaction. Whenever you are
dealing with an entity, you must always remember that the entity may avoid
liability if it can prove that the person who signed the agreement in question
did not have proper authority to legally bind the entity. The buyer's
obligations under a purchase agreement should be contingent on obtaining written
evidence from the selling entity that the person who signed the agreement on
behalf of the entity was authorized to do so and that the governing authority
for the entity approved the transaction. Proper written evidence of
authority consists
of:
(i) for a corporation: resolutions adopted by the Board of Directors
signed by all of the directors or certified to by an appropriate corporate
officer that approve the transaction and authorize an officer to sign on behalf
of the corporation, or
(ii) for a limited liability company: a copy of the company's Operating
Agreement that shows either the signer has authority to bind the company without
the need for member approval or, if member approval is required, appropriate
resolutions adopted by the members that shows that the members approved the
transaction and authorized the manager to sign on behalf of the company.
-
Perform a judgment, lien and bankruptcy search on the sellers and all
entities involved. Arizona law provides that a purchaser of an asset
owned by a seller that has outstanding judgments and liens takes the asset
subject to the judgments and liens. Most buyers know that if you buy land
that is subject to a deed of trust, the buyer acquires the land subject to the
lien and must satisfy it or risk losing the land. The same principle
applies to buying tangible and intangible assets. If I buy all the
inventory of ABC, Inc., and the inventory is subject to a security interest of
XYZ Incorporated, I must satisfy the lien or XYZ may seize the inventory I
purchased and sell it at a public or private sale to pay the debt.
At a minimum, buyers should check for judgments, liens and bankruptcies on file
with each of the following government agencies:
(i) for judgments: Check the superior court in the county in which the
party resides and in each county in which the party does business to see if
there are any lawsuits on file in which the party is or was involved. If
there are lawsuits, you must investigate each to determine if any judgments were
issued by the court against the party. If you find any judgments or other
pertinent information, make copies and review the documents carefully. See
the
Maricopa County Superior Court's online case history.
(ii) for judgments and liens: Check the documents recorded with the County
Recorder in the county in which the party resides and in each county in which
the party does business to see if there are any judgments or liens recorded in
which the party is named. If you find any recorded judgments or liens, or
other pertinent information, make copies and review the documents carefully.
See the
Maricopa County Recorder's online document search engine.
(iii) for liens on personal property (tangible and intangible): Check the
Uniform Commercial Code financing statements and related documents on file with
the Arizona Secretary of State. Arizona law provides that creditors
protect their lien claims against debtors by filing a UCC-1 financing statement
with the Arizona Secretary of State to give notice to the world of the existence
of their lien. See the
Arizona
Secretary of State's online UCC lien search engine.
(iv) for bankruptcies: Check the
U.S. Bankruptcy Court for
the District of Arizona to see if each party is currently in bankruptcy or
filed for bankruptcy in the past. If a party is currently in bankruptcy,
consult with an Arizona bankruptcy attorney to determine what steps, if any, you
should take to protect your position as a result of the bankruptcy.
If a party resides outside Arizona, you should perform similar investigations in
the state and county where the party resides.
- Verify all representations made by the seller and confirm that the
representations are true.
Example. If the seller states that its use of the leased premises
complies with applicable zoning law, confirm with the city, county or other
appropriate governmental agency that the zoning is adequate for the buyer's
intended use of the premises. If the seller represents that the business has generated
certain gross
revenue in each of the last three years, demand copies of the
seller's federal income tax returns and financial statements for the periods in
question. Tax returns are excellent evidence of the historical income and
expenses of a business. Caution: Beware of a seller who
claims that the information on a filed tax return (under reported income and
over stated deductions) is incorrect. This seller is admitting tax fraud,
and if the seller will lie to the IRS and risk criminal charges to pay less tax,
what are the chances the seller is telling you the truth?
- Obtain copies of all pertinent contracts and documents and approve the
contents of each one. The purchase agreement should state that true
and complete copies of all contracts to be assumed by the buyer (in an asset
purchase) or for which the purchased entity will remain liable after closing
(in an entity purchase) are attached as exhibits to the purchase agreement.
Carefully review all the contracts and make sure that you are willing to
satisfy all obligations of all the contracts.
Example. If the buyer is assuming the World Wide Widget contract, the
buyer must review the contract because the buyer will have to satisfy all
obligations under the contract after closing.
-
Obtain a copy of all real estate leases and approve the contents of each one.
If the buyer will assume a lease, the buyer must obtain a copy of the lease and
all amendments and make sure that all provisions are acceptable because the
buyer will become legally obligated to satisfy all terms and conditions of the
lease, as modified.
-
Obtain the consent of all landlords if the buyer is to occupy premises leased
by the seller or by the entity. Most commercial leases contain
provisions that give the landlord the right to declare the lease in default if
the tenant transfers all or any interest in the lease without the landlord's
consent. A buyer who purchases a business without obtaining the consent of
the landlord risks being evicted after closing or at best, a substantial
increase in the rent in return for obtaining the landlord's consent to the
transfer. When a landlord has a right to approve a transfer of the
tenant's interest in the lease, an assignment of the lease from a seller to a
buyer obviously requires the landlord's consent, but the same is also true in an
entity purchase situation where there is only a change of ownership if the lease
has language that states that a change in ownership of the entity is deemed to
be a transfer of an interest in the lease.
-
Verify the condition and other pertinent facts concerning all material assets
being purchased. This one is a no brainer. If you are buying a
car, you should have its condition inspected by a knowledgeable mechanic.
This concept applies if you are buying an office building, a franchise, a
business that sells widgets or any other business. The buyer should have
knowledgeable people inspect the assets being purchased.
-
Inventory the inventory. If you are buying inventory (especially if
part of the purchase price is based on inventory on hand at closing), inspect the
inventory before closing and do an actual inventory as of the closing date to
verify the number of units being purchased and their condition.
-
Determine if the buyer will be liable for the seller's
Arizona unemployment insurance account. Arizona law provides
that a buyer of an entire business that continues the seller's operation will be
assigned the tax rate and experience rating account of the seller. The
experience rating account includes the record of wages and taxes previously
paid. Any unemployment benefits awarded based on wages paid by the former
business owner may be charged to the buyer's account. The buyer may also
be liable for the former owner's unpaid unemployment taxes.
Caution: The purchase agreement should
contain a mechanism to compensate the buyer if the buyer will incur additional
expense after closing arising from becoming liable for the seller's unemployment
insurance account.
A buyer that acquires a portion of a business and continues to operate it is not
automatically assigned the tax rate and experience rating account of the former
owner. To apply for a portion of the account and its corresponding tax
rate, the buyer must file an "Application
& Agreement for Severable Portion Experience Rating Transfer" (UC-247)
within 180 days of acquiring the business. The former owner must agree and
provide payroll information for the portions of the business acquired and
retained. The buyer's account may then be charged for a portion of the
unemployment benefits paid to the former owner's employees.
The above list of due diligence items is not meant to be all inclusive. It
is a list of the minimum due diligence tasks that should be performed by all
buyers. Each particular business
purchase will have its own due diligence requirements that may require
additional due diligence beyond the tasks referred to above.
Buyers that buy or lease real estate in connection with the purchase of a business or
purchase of an entity that owns or leases real estate have additional due
diligence requirements that are real estate related and outside the scope of
this article. Real estate due diligence, includes, but is not limited to:
(i) obtaining an environmental assessment that shows the land is free of
environmental problems, (ii) reviewing and approving the state of the title and
liens, encumbrances and other items that affect title, (iii) obtaining and
approving surveys, (iv) verifying zoning and that the intended use of the land
is not prohibited by applicable zoning and conditions, covenants and
restrictions that encumber the land, and (v) obtaining acceptable tenant
estoppel certificates from all tenants, if any, that occupy the land.
Can a Buyer Cancel a Purchase if there is a Problem?
The short answer is yes, no and maybe? The answer to the question depends
on the language of the purchase agreement. If the purchase agreement does
not contain a review period or any language that gives the buyer the right to
cancel if a problem arises, the buyer may be legally bound to close.
Buyers who discover a problem before closing and who do not clearly have the
right to cancel a purchase agreement should consult a business attorney
immediately to determine their rights.
I had a client once that signed a simple contract that said "I will by your
widget for $50,000." My client later decided she did not want to buy the
widget. Unfortunately, the client could not unilaterally terminate the
contract because it did not contain any conditions or "outs." The result
would have been different if the contract said, for example, "I will buy your
widget for $50,000 if I obtain financing satisfactory to me in my sole
discretion within ten days of this agreement" and I applied for and was not able
to obtain satisfactory financing. In this case, the condition precedent to
my obligation to buy is not satisfied so I can terminate the purchase agreement.
A prudent buyer will sign a purchase agreement that gives the buyer a free look
period of time to investigate and perform due diligence during which time the
buyer may cancel the purchase agreement for any reason and receive a refund of
all earnest money. This is the best type of provision because the buyer
can cancel without any reason.
A prudent buyer will also provide in the purchase agreement that the buyer has
the option to cancel the purchase agreement and receive a refund of all earnest
money if any important events do not occur. For example, if the buyer is
to assume a real estate lease, the purchase agreement should expressly state
that the buyer's obligation to close is contingent on obtaining the landlord's
consent to the assignment of the lease without any conditions that are
unacceptable to the buyer. This type of express condition gives the buyer
an option to cancel if it is not satisfied.
Before the buyer signs a purchase agreement, the buyer must make sure that its
allows for an appropriate due diligence period, express conditions to closing
and that the buyer can cancel to purchase agreement and receive a refund of all
earnest money if any problems are discovered or conditions are not satisfied.
A party is free to waive unsatisfied conditions and unresolved problems and
close. The real issue is whether it is prudent to do so. If the
buyer finds a material problem before closing and has a right under the purchase
agreement to not close, normally the buyer should refuse to close unless and
until the problem is resolved to the buyer's satisfaction. The same is
true of material conditions in a purchase agreement that are not satisfied
before closing. The buyer has the most leverage with the seller to resolve
problems and unsatisfied conditions before closing and the seller gets paid. Buyers
should normally not close a purchase transaction when a problem
is found before closing or a condition to close is not satisfied unless the buyer is willing to take the risk that the problem
or condition will not
be resolved after closing.
If a buyer elects to close despite unresolved problems and unsatisfied
conditions, the buyer should try to modify the purchase documents to in a way
that will reduce potential problems after closing. For example, if a
condition to closing is that a certain asset be free and clear of a $5,000 lien
owed to ABC Creditor, Inc., and the lien remains of record at closing, the buyer
could be protected if $5,000 of the closing proceeds is held in escrow until the
lien is released or paid to the creditor if the lien is not released by a
specified date.
Arizona business purchases typically include the following legal documents:
- Purchase Agreement
- Escrow Agreement
- Bill of Sale
- Promissory Note
- Security Agreement and/or Deed of Trust
- UCC-1 Financing Statement
- Guaranty
- Assignment of Lease
- Consent of Landlord to Assignment of Lease
- Covenant not to Compete
- Consulting Agreement
The primary document that evidences an agreement to buy or sell a business
(entity purchase or asset purchase) is the purchase contract. It may be
called "Asset Purchase Agreement," "Purchase Agreement," Purchase & Sale
Agreement," "Stock Purchase Agreement" or something similar. This is the
most important agreement because it sets forth the "deal points," i.e., all the
terms and conditions applicable to the sale.
When I prepare documents for a business purchase, my purchase agreement includes
all ancillary documents as an exhibit to the purchase agreement so that at the
time the parties sign the purchase agreement they agree on the exact form and
contents of all the ancillary documents. This practice prevents disputes
between the parties before closing as to the provisions that should be in the
ancillary documents.
The above list is typical of business purchases, but is not all inclusive.
Each particular purchase transaction has its own special documentation needs
that may require all or a portion of the above-referenced documents or
additional documents.
Can You Explain the Common Purchase Documents?
-
Purchase Agreement: This is the most
important document because it sets the purchase price and the other terms and
conditions of the purchase. It should state all material terms and
conditions and include representations and warranties of the seller with
respect to all important matters relating to the transaction.
-
Escrow Agreement: If an escrow is used for
the purchase, the parties should have an Escrow Agreement among the parties
and an independent escrow agent. The purpose of the escrow is allow a
neutral party to hold items submitted by each party until closing and then
deliver the items to the appropriate party. For example, the escrow
agent should hold the buyer's down payment money until all closing conditions
are satisfied then at closing deliver the money to the seller and deliver the
Bill of Sale and other asset assignment documents to the buyer. If a
purchase does not involve an escrow, this document is not necessary.
-
Bill of Sale: This is a document signed by
the seller and delivered at closing that evidences the seller's assignment and
transfer of the assets listed in the Bill of Sale to the buyer.
-
Deed: If the purchase involves the
acquisition of real property, title is transferred by a deed signed by the
owner of the land (and notarized) and recorded with the County Recorder of the
County in which the land is located.
-
Promissory Note: If the entire purchase
price is not paid at closing, the balance owed should be evidenced by a
Promissory Note signed by the buyer that sets forth the terms of future
payments.
-
Security Agreement and/or Deed of Trust: An
unpaid balance owed at closing that is evidenced by a Promissory Note may or
may note be secured by a lien on property. A prudent seller that does
not get paid in full will insist on a lien on property of the buyer and
property of guarantors (if the buyer is an entity and the Promissory Note is
guaranteed by any third parties) to secure payment of the debt. Whether
any property will be encumbered to secure payment of a debt is entirely a
matter of negotiation between the parties. Security Agreements are
documents that create liens on personal property. Deeds of Trusts (and
Mortgages - used infrequently in Arizona) create liens on real property.
-
UCC-1 Financing Statement: This important
document is used only if the transaction involves a lien on personal property.
A prudent seller of an Arizona business or assets located in Arizona and who
that takes a Promissory Note to evidence an unpaid balance owed at closing
that is secured by a lien on personal property should always file a UCC-1
Financing Statement with the Arizona Secretary of State to perfect the lien
and give notice to the world that the seller has a lien on the assets listed
in the UCC-1. If the debtor does not reside in Arizona or is formed in a
state other than Arizona, the seller should also file a similar document in
the state in which the debtor resides and in the state in which the debtor is
formed (if the debtor is an entity). See our
Arizona Uniform Commercial Code links.
-
Guaranty: When the buyer is an entity, a
prudent seller that does not get paid in full at closing or is concerned about
the buyer satisfying post-closing covenants should obtain a guaranty from
owners of the buyer that they will satisfy the buyer's obligations if the
buyer defaults.
Caution: Arizona law provides that if
only one spouse signs a guaranty, the creditor can satisfy a judgment arising
from the guaranty only from the separate property of the spouse that signed
the guaranty, but cannot reach the married couple's community property.
For this reason, whenever a creditor seeks a guaranty from a married person,
the creditor should obtain the signature of both spouses on the guaranty
unless the creditor is willing to satisfy a judgment only from the signer's
separate property (if there is any separate property).
-
Assignment of Lease: This document is used
only if the purchase of assets also involves the buyer's acquisition of the
seller's interest as a tenant in a lease. It is the document that
evidences and assigns to the buyer the seller's rights in and to the lease.
-
Consent of Landlord to Assignment of Lease:
If a lease is being assigned or if the buyer intends to use or occupy the
property subject to the lease and if the lessor of the lease has a right to
approve all assignments of the lease, the buyer must obtain the lessor's
signature on this document.
-
Covenant Not to Compete: A prudent buyer of
a business will obtain the written agreement of the seller and key owners of a
seller that is an entity by which they promise that they will not compete with
the business being purchased. Without an agreement not to compete, a
seller and the seller's owners and affiliates are usually free to open a
competing business across the street from the buyer's new business. A
buyer may also allocate a portion of the purchase price to the Covenant Not to
Compete and amortize it over the life of the covenant or in accordance with
IRS guidelines.
Caution: Arizona courts will not
enforce Covenants Not to Compete if they are too broad in duration, scope or
area. A Covenant Not to Compete intended to be enforceable under Arizona
law should be prepared by an Arizona attorney familiar with applicable Arizona
law.
- Consulting Agreement: A Consulting Agreement (for independent
contractors) or Employment Agreement (for employees) should be used if the
buyer wants to obligate one or more key personnel affiliated with the seller
to assist the buyer during a transition period after closing.
If an Arizona business broker is involved, the broker may prepare the purchase
agreement and related documents. Disregarding the issue of whether the
broker who prepares the documents is practicing law without a license, the
parties should ask themselves "who does the broker represent when preparing the
documents?" If the broker represents the seller, the broker may prepare
the documents to favor the seller.
Even if the broker prepares "neutral" documents, the documents may not
sufficiently protect the buyer. Usually the broker's most important
objective is for the deal to close so the broker can get the commission.
Many broker prepared purchase agreements and ancillary documents are drafted to
not "rock the boat" or create issues that might cause the buyer or seller to
refuse to sign the purchase agreement.
Of course being an Arizona business lawyer I am prejudiced, but I recommend
without exception that every buyer of an Arizona business consult with an
experienced business attorney before becoming obligated to purchase. The
relatively small legal fees paid to an Arizona lawyer will probably be
insignificant when compared to the buyer's large investment to purchase the
business. Unless the investment is nominal, buying a business is not the
time to be "pennywise and pound foolish" and rely on a business broker or
standard form documents to protect the buyer's investment.
Is Earnest Money Required to Have a Binding Contract?
No. Contrary to popular belief, Arizona law does not require that the
buyer of an Arizona business pay any earnest money to create a legally binding
agreement. Whether to pay earnest money and the amount thereof is entirely
a matter of negotiations between the parties. The buyer should try to
eliminate earnest money entirely or if that is not possible, negotiate the
smallest amount possible.
An escrow is a device created by an agreement between three or more parties to
accomplish specific purposes. Escrows are commonly used in connection with
business purchases to make sure that the buyer and the seller each satisfy all
conditions to closing before the purchase actually closes. Escrows are
used to protect the interests of buyer and seller.
The parties to a business purchase escrow are the buyer, the seller and an
escrow agent. The escrow agent should be an independent third party.
Arizona law requires that an escrow agent that is in the business of acting as
an escrow agent must be licensed as an escrow agent by the Arizona State Banking
Department.
In a business purchase escrow, the following events should occur:
- The buyer pays the purchase money (or delivers a check payable to the
proper party) to the escrow agent and signs all necessary documents required
of the buyer and delivers the documents to the escrow agent.
- The seller signs all documents required of the seller (such as the Bill of
Sale and Assignment of Lease) and delivers the documents to the escrow agent.
- The escrow agent holds the buyer's funds, the buyer's documents and the
seller's document in the escrow until the transaction closes or dies.
- If the transaction dies, the escrow agent returns the money and documents
to the parties designated in the escrow agreement and/or in the purchase
documents. Unless there is an agreement to the contrary, if the
transaction does not close and the buyer is not in default, all money
deposited into escrow is returned to the buyer.
- If one party defaults, the escrow agent's duties are as set forth in the
escrow agreement and/or the purchase documents.
- If the buyer and seller disagree with any proposed action by the escrow
agent, a prudent escrow agent will refuse to act until both parties agree to
the proposed action or a court authorizes the action.
- If all conditions to closing are satisfied, the escrow agent pays the
purchase proceeds to the seller, delivers to the seller the purchase documents
deliverable to the seller, and delivers to the buyer the purchase documents
deliverable to the buyer.
Escrow agreements should be in writing and signed by the buyer, the seller and
the escrow agent. I recommend that the escrow agent always be an
independent third party that is licensed to act as an escrow agent by the
Arizona State Banking Department. Commercial escrow companies charge a fee
for their services.
An escrow is not required, but it is usually in the best interests of both
parties to use an escrow with a licensed escrow agent.
Before a buyer signs a purchase agreement, the buyer should keep in mind that
every thing in the agreement is negotiable. The purchase agreement should
be one-sided in favor of the buyer because the buyer is paying the money to
purchase the business and should get the full benefit of the bargain.
The following is a partial list of additional legal issues that a buyer should
seek to resolve in the purchase agreement:
-
Use an asset purchase method.
In general, buyers should use their best efforts to negotiate an asset purchase
to reduce the risk of paying unknown and/or unwanted obligations of the seller
and to obtain a higher tax basis in the purchased assets. Buyers should
discuss whether to use an asset purchase or an entity purchase acquisition
method with their advisors because there are exceptions to the general rule that
the asset purchase method is the preferred method.
-
For entity purchases. A buyer that agrees to an entity purchase (rather than an asset purchase) needs an especially tough purchase
agreement that: (i) describes all obligations of the company that the buyer is
willing to allow the company to pay after closing, and (ii) obligates the seller to indemnify and hold
the buyer harmless for all obligations of the company paid or incurred by the
company after closing that were not expressly agreed to be paid in the purchase
agreement.
-
Provide a method to resolve post-closing problems. Anticipate
potential post-closing problems and include provisions in the purchase agreement
to resolve the problems if they arise. For example, if a buyer thinks it
may need assistance from a key person employed by seller or from the seller, add
a condition to buyer's obligation to close that the buyer enter into an
acceptable contract at closing with the key person. If the buyer is
concerned about becoming obligated to paying debts of the seller that are to
remain payable by the seller, put some of the down payment money in an escrow to
be held for a period of time after closing and used to pay the debts if
necessary.
-
Consider a personal guaranty. The seller will be obligated to
satisfy all of its obligations under the purchase documents. Caution:
If the seller is an entity, keep in mind that if any problems arise after
closing, the seller may not have sufficient assets to satisfy the buyer's
damages for breach of contract. A prudent buyer dealing with an entity
will insist that the owners of the entity seller personally guaranty the
obligations of the seller.
This article is not intended to give legal advice. Each particular
prospective purchase has its own unique facts and circumstances that may involve
some or all of the issues raised herein and other legal considerations not
mentioned above. I recommend that every buyer and every seller of a
business be represented by an experienced business attorney licensed in the
jurisdiction where the sale occurs.
KEYTLaw's Business Purchase & Sale Document Preparation
Service
If you are buying or selling an Arizona business, you should hire Arizona
business law attorney Richard Keyt (practicing since 1980) to
prepare all the legal documents necessary to document the transaction. For
a low guaranteed fixed fee, we will prepare all the following documents
customized to favor the buyer (if we represent the buyer) or the seller (if we
represent the seller):
- Purchase Agreement
- Escrow Agreement
- Bill of Sale
- Promissory Note
- Security Agreement
- Deed of Trust
- UCC-1 Financing Statement
- Guaranty
- Assignment of Lease
- Consent of Landlord to Assignment of Lease
- Covenant not to Compete
- Consulting Agreement
Each document is custom prepared by Richard Keyt specifically for the buyer's
transaction.
We prepare the above-referenced 12 documents for a fixed fee of $2,000
($167/document). The fixed fee includes unlimited consultations and
telephone calls at no additional charge up to the delivery of the first draft of
all the documents. The fixed fee also includes up to two hours (at no
charge) of additional time after delivery of the documents for conferences,
negotiations with the other side and changes to the documents.
Call Rick Keyt today at 602-906-4953 or email at
rickkeyt@keytlaw.com and take the
first step to protecting your valuable investment.
This article was first published on September 1, 2003.
About the Author
Richard
Keyt, J.D., LL.M. (income taxation New York University Law School) is a business, real estate, transactions, contracts and estate planning attorney licensed to practice law in Arizona. He has
formed over 1,500+ Arizona limited liability companies in the last few
years because his low cost high quality LLC package is second to none
and it only costs $599 for everything. Rick has practiced law in Arizona since 1980.
Rick can be reached by telephone at 602-906-4953, ext. 101. Email
at rickkeyt@keytlaw.com
and fax at 602-297-6890.
Rick's web site located at
www.keytlaw.com had over 1,000,000
visitors in 2006 and 2007.
Rick does not accept matters involving landlord / tenant disputes or
litigation of any kind (other than tax lien foreclosures). Communicating with Richard Keyt via email or otherwise does not cause
you to become a client or cause your communications to be confidential
or subject to the attorney client privilege.