HomeAboutContactOffice LocationDownloadsSearchForm LLC Now

TestimonialsFree NewslettersSite MapSend Page to FriendOur Store

 

LLCsCorporationsReal EstateEstate PlanningLandlord LawAZ LawStatutes

LLC Library
KEYTLaw Store
Attorneys & Staff
What's New
Table of Contents
Fixed Fee Services
Arizona Law
AZ Statutes
Corporation Library
Estate Plan Library
IRA Library
Probate FAQ
Real Estate Law
Landlord Tenant
Copyright Law
Trademark Law
Domain Name Law
Internet Law
IRS Items
Rick Keyt's Articles
Links
Free Newsletters
About Rick Keyt
Contact Information
Office Map
Website Statistics
Flying the F-4
Inspirational Words
Law Office Tech
KEYTLaw Software
For Lawyer Authors

______________

Previous

Next

Bogus Domain Names
Do Not Call List
Auction Fraud
Pretexting
Anthrax Cure
Cancer Cures
Spam
Spam I
Spam II
Spam III
Spam IV
Spam V
Spam Harvest
Spam & Junk Faxes
FTC Actions Home
John Zuccarini
John Zuccarini II
Illegal Billing
Phone Scam
User Data
Liverite Claims
Comfrey II
Comfrey I
Internet Access
Credit Repair
Access Fees
Access Fees II
Online Learning
Healthcare Fraud I
Healthcare Fraud II
Healthcare Products
Healthcare Products II
Snore Formula
Internet Services
Free Services
Junk Faxes
COPPA Fines
COPPA Fines II
COPPA Fines III
COPPA Fines IV
COPPA IV
Web Crammers
Bogus Charges
Pyramid Scheme
Pyramid Scheme II
Pyramid Scheme III
Pyramid Scheme IV
Domain Name Scam
Domain Name Scam II
Domain Name Scam III
Page Jacking
Work at Home
Work At Home II
Work at Home III
Country of Origin
Mail Order Rule
Mail Order Rule II
Mail Order Rule III
Mail Order Rule IV
Playgirl.com

You are here: Home  FTC Actions FTC Internet Enforcement Bigsmart

Bigsmart Pyramid Promoters Settle FTC Charges

$5 Million for Consumer Redress

March 27, 2001

Operators of an Internet-based business opportunity that promised easy income for investors in an Internet shopping mall network have agreed to settle Federal Trade Commission charges that their scheme was an illegal pyramid operation. Under the terms of the settlement, Bigsmart.Com L.L.C. and principals Mark and Harry Tahiliani will provide up to $5 million in consumer redress and post a $500,000 performance bond before engaging in any new multi-level marketing activity. The defendants also are prohibited from engaging in any illegal pyramid schemes.

Bigsmart is based in Mesa, Arizona.

According to the FTC complaint detailing the charges, Bigsmart marketed Internet theme "malls" that it claimed would enable investors to earn substantial income from commissions on products purchased through the Internet. The malls were a collection of links to retail sites maintained by independent third-party merchants, such as MarthaStewart.com, and to a "Superstore" maintained by Bigsmart, itself. Traffic was directed to the malls through the personalized Bigsmart "welcome pages" that members bought access to for a $10 application fee and a $99.95 "hosting" fee. Although Bigsmart claimed that members would make substantial amounts of money, the scheme was structured in such way that to realize continued financial gains, would depend on ". . . the continued, successive recruitment of other participants," not on retail sales of products and services to the public. The FTC charged that the claims that consumers who invested in Bigsmart would make substantial income were false; that promotional materials that made the false and misleading claims provided the means and instrumentalities for others to deceive consumers; and that Bigsmart was actually a pyramid scheme. All three were violations of the FTC Act.

To settle the FTC charges, Bigsmart and the Tahilianis will provide up to $5 million in consumer redress. They also will be required to post a $500,000 performance bond before engaging in any new multi-level marketing activity.

Consumers who believe they may qualify to receive consumer redress should call 202-326-3294.

This case was brought with the invaluable assistance of the Offices of the Attorney General of Texas and the Wisconsin. Department of Agriculture, Trade, & Consumer Protection, Division of Trade & Consumer Protection. It was filed in U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona, March 12, 2001.

Related Documents:

FTC v. Bigsmart.com L.L.C.; Mark Tahiliani; and Harry Tahiliani (District Court of Arizona)

Complaint [PDF 664K]

Stipulated Final Order [PDF 1.36M]

Stipulated Permanent Injunction [PDF 3.12M]

Order Appointing Equity Receiver [PDF 279K]

The above article was reprinted from an announcement on the Federal Trade Commission web site dated March 27, 2001.  Check the FTC web site for any changes to the article.

 

This page was last modified on July 22, 2007.

Send Page To a Friend

Subscribe to Richard Keyt's Free Email Newsletters

 

Privacy Policy | Disclaimers | Terms of Use | Suggestions  | Credit Card Security

Website Created by & Copyright ©  2001-2008 Richard Keyt, All Rights Reserved